

Discrimination in the EU is revealed in its breadth in the special Eurobarometer report 493 'Discrimination in the European Union', published in October 2019. (1) Beyond the most recent extreme phenomena - from the threats to Senator Liliana Segre in Italy, to the neo-Nazi alarm declared in Dresden - the prejudice against minorities and diversity remains effective, daily and widespread .
The analysis of the 'public opinion' considers the levels of discrimination in the EU against groups of people (gender and LGBTI, creed and religion, disability) and ethnic minorities (ethnicities and 'skin color'). In relation to the different social dimensions (sentimental, work, political).
the work was conducted through interviews vis-à-vis of 27.438 people, belonging to different social and demographic groups, in the 28 member countries. On behalf of the European Commission, Directorate-General for Consumers and Justice. Keeping in mind the equality requirements established in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. (2)
In general, tolerance levels - expressed with the euphemism of 'comfort and ease' - are lower towards people of Roma ethnicity, intersex and transgender. All the more so when relationships affect the family sphere (as in the case of a romantic relationship with one's children). Intolerance decreases when the person at risk of discrimination is a colleague. And it reaches a decent level of acceptance when 'the different' takes on a political office, even in a high position.
The 2019 Eurobarometer - following an extensive opinion poll - it offers a real ranking of shame. That is to say, the groups of people towards which European citizens feel there is discrimination:
- people of Roma or Roma ethnicity (61%),
- individuals of other ethnicities and different skin colors (59%),
- people of non-heterosexual orientation (l, gay, bisexual, 53%, transgender 48%),
- human beings of various beliefs and religions (47%),
- people with disabilities (44%).
People with disabilities suffer widespread discrimination, 63% of French citizens recognize. In short, a revolution was not enough to affirm the values of Brotherhood ed Égalité (!). The prejudice towards the disabled is recognized, in Italy, by 1 citizen out of 2. And it is only thanks to the higher level of civilization of the Northern European countries that the average tolerance towards the handicapped reaches 56%. But only 49%, it should be noted, among young people (15-24 years).
The problem it is therefore cultural, (in primis). And the only apparently favorable data, the growing acceptance of a disabled colleague (84%), is purely unrealistic. As the levels of unemployment linked to disability are unmatched. And this is the real stigma, with a social impact that Eurostat shows in terms of the prevalence of risk of poverty and social exclusion (28,7% vs. 19,2%, the gap between disabled and non-disabled).
Cultural barriers, moreover, they are also expressed in the systematic violation of the freedom of the handicapped. With all due respect to the solemn principles affirmed in the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). (3) Ubiquitous architectural barriers, inaccessible travel services e personal mobility non-existent complete the picture of denied rights.
The discomfort expressed towards persons and groups at risk of discrimination is more pronounced towards the Roma community than towards groups of other ethnic groups, 'colors' or faiths. Only 39% of European citizens interviewed said they feel at ease if their children have Roma classmates. The racism of ancient memory therefore persists. It is most pronounced in France (75%) and Italy (71%) and gradually scales northward (41% in Finland).
At the same time however, less than one in 5 Europeans (19%) consider the efforts made in their country to be effective for Roma inclusion. 28% believe that such efforts are moderately effective and 34%, at least that, recognize their total inadequacy. Without, however, that politics - at European level as well as in individual Member States - does anything.
This social crisis affects 12 million individuals in Europe, 80% of whom live below the poverty line. The life expectancy of the members of this community, it should be noted, is 10 years below the average.
The LBGTI community (l, gays, bisexual, transgender and intersex) instead seems to be finally coming out of the proscription lists of European citizens. Indeed, the Eurobarometer shows an improvement compared to the previous survey of 2015. 76% of Europeans today recognize equal rights for gay, lesbian, bisexual and intersex people. 72% consider that there is nothing wrong in the emotional relationship between two people of the same sex and 69% say they are in favor of same-sex marriages.
Official documents, for 46% of the subjects interviewed, should contemplate a third option for those who do not attribute to themselves a male or female identity. 42% maintain the opposite position, the remaining 12% say they 'don't know'. With significant variations between the different countries, with greater indulgence in Malta (67%) and Spain (63%), extreme rigor in Bulgaria (7%) and Hungary (13%). In Italy the no still dominates (49%, compared with 37% in favor).
Most of the European citizens interviewed consider it appropriate to introduce lectures and didactic material on 'diversity' in schools. Especially when it comes to disability (86% in favor), ethnic origin or skin color (82%), creed and religion (81%).
Consent education - which is the logical premise of tolerance - on the other hand decreases when we consider the idea of including references to Roma history and culture in teaching (72% in favor). And above all when dealing with the issue of variables relating to sexuality. Only 65% of the sample interviewed is actually in favor of offering information, in the school context, on being transgender or intersex.
Discrimination in Italy it is markedly more pronounced than the European average. Against Roma (79%, compared to 61% of the EU average) but also towards skin color, sexual orientation, transgender. Italians are also less willing to work with Roma people (with a 'greater discomfort' expressed by 39% of the interviewees, compared to 17% on the EU average). Indeed, 1 in 4 'he would not feel comfortable'whether a gay, lesbian or bisexual person occupied the highest elected office in the country (24%, vs. 18%).
Not even at school Italians agree to accept information on 'diversity'. Only 47% agree that schools inform about transgender and 49% on intersexuality (65% the average in the EU), 56% on sexual orientation (71% in the EU). Finally, only 53% (versus 72% in the European Union) agree that at school we talk about Roma history and culture.
Dario Dongo and Sabrina Bergamini
Note
(1) European Commission. (2019). Special Eurobarometer 493, Discrimination in the European Union,
(2) See Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, 2012 / C 326/02. Title III, Equality, Articles 20-26. On https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/IT/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A12012P%2FTXT
(3) See also Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, article 26, Integration of people with disabilities. 'The Union recognizes and respects the right of persons with disabilities to benefit from measures designed to guarantee their autonomy, social and occupational integration and participation in the life of the community.'

Dario Dongo, lawyer and journalist, PhD in international food law, founder of WIISE (FARE - GIFT - Food Times) and Égalité.